[HPforGrownups] Snape vs Fake!Moody (was:Bullying WAS: Re: Prodigal Sons)

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 141083

Maybe it was. But I must say that when Barty Crouch was dementor-
kissed in the end of GoF it was even more of a poetic justice 
and "karmic punishment".
a_svirn


Sherry now:

I was horrified when Barty was kissed.  Even though I knew what he had done,
the idea of *anyone* being kissed by a dementor was terrible.  Even though I
believe Snape killed Dumbledore, and that it was not a plan or mercy
killing, i would be appalled if his fate was to be kissed by a dementor.  He
would have sent Sirius and Lupin to that fate, but I would be at the head of
the pack, picketing and chanting not to have him or any other person kissed.
So, at least I'm consistent in a way.  I can't imagine any good reason for
Snape to kill Dumbledore, any reason that would make sense or excuse it.
But then, i can't imagine anyone's crimes, no matter how terrible, deserving
the dementor kiss.  Punishment, sure.  even Azkaban.  Powers taken away, if
that can be done, but no dementors.  They are terrible creatures.  Shudder.

Sherry