Harry IS Snape.

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 141292

Sherry:
> I don't think that is the law in the US, otherwise Jack--can't spell his
> last name, the so called doctor who practices physician assisted
> suicide--would not have been put on trial and gone to prison for his
> actions. 

Carol:
Kevorkian?

Sherry:
 And personally, I find that kind of scary, because anyone who
> could determine the situation in the right percentage could get away
with murder.  My hair raises with fear over that one.  For me, it all
still comes down to the fact that Snape killed Dumbledore.  I don't
care why or how; what curse it was or wasn't.  Unless Dumbledore is
secretly alive and it was all an elaborate hoax, nothing will excuse
Snape to me.
  
Carol:
Even if killing him was the only way to save Draco and Harry and get
the Death Eaters out of the school? If Snape had died (killed by the
UV or the Death Eaters), quite possibly both boys would have died as
well. And there was no way to save Dumbledore, who would have been
killed by the Death Eaters if he wasn't killed by the potion first.

I'm not saying that's the case, but *if* it's the case, wouldn't it at
least complicate matters and partially excuse Snape? It does for me.

Carol