[HPforGrownups] A Cold Equation (was Re: The Trial Of Severus Snape)

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 141361

> ...snipped...
> Come on now, Sherry. *If* Snape was acting for the greater good when
> he killed Dumbledore and *if* he really had no choice, wouldn't you
> forgive him? It's only a hypothetical proposition, and I went along
> with yours. <smiles sweetly>

 .
Kemper smiling as sweetly to Sherry:
I agree with the consequences of every condition that Carol has addressed
including the last which Sherry has avoided thus far. (Friendly wave)
.


Sherry

Sorry, i thought I made it clear. no. i do not forgive Snape.  i do not
believe the so called greater good demands killing Dumbledore.  It's just
not the way I think.  Sorry, but Snape firmly with Voldemort, Draco saved
from his own idiocy and all the rest, does not justify Dumbledore being
killed.  I just can't express it strongly enough.  A soldier does not kill
his own general.  There's no greater good that can justify it.  I would not
forgive him for it, ever.  murder is the ultimate sin, and taking another
person's life, for *any* reason is the ultimate sin.  not speaking
religiously.  So, no, i would not forgive Snape, because nothing would
justify it to me.  There could have been some other way.  

Sherry