Reasonable Doubt.
eggplant107
eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Mon Oct 10 05:37:30 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 141373
"M.Clifford" <Aisbelmon at h...> wrote:
> if Dumbledore had fallen, slumped,
> at the moment the curse touched his
> body with a blank, empty expression
> in his staring eyes, then it would
> be unequivocally decided that the
> Avada Kedavra was the cause of death.
I submit that only one time have we seen Avada Kedavra work like you
describe above, at other times the victims had a look of terror on
their face not a blank expression, on another occasion it left a
physical mark on the intended victim, another time it did not,
sometimes it causes absolutely no damage, another time it destroyed a
house, yet another time it smashed a very large statue. I see nothing
unusual in the way that curse worked that night on that tower.
> Dumbledore is thrown bodily from the tower
Well of course he is, JKR isn't about to let a very major character
just close his eyes and die, he was after all in the highest tower at
Hogwarts so he must fall dramatically off.
Eggplant
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive