Bill will die!

[saturniia]

No: HPFGUIDX 141422

Brothergib wrote:
> In HBP, we are informed that Bill is a curse breaker.
> 
> I think that Bill will attempt to break the curse on the locket. But 
> since DD only survived due to his 'prodigous skill' and Snape's 
> intervention, I think it may be curtains for poor old Bill!!

We are informed in GoF that Bill is a Curse-Breaker, not HBP.  Also, 
comparing a young, vital man accomplished in the specialization of 
breaking curses to an old autodidact headmaster is like comparing a 
scalpel to a trusted Swiss Army knife.  Yes, the Swiss Army knife is 
sturdy, and it will help you in hundreds of situations, but it has 
limitations in each field that the individual components do not have.  
The scalpel, on the other hand, may be ineffective when one is trying 
to tighten a screw or uncork a bottle, but when it comes to making 
easy, precise cuts, the more specific instrument is the way to go.

I'm not saying that Bill won't die, but to say it so definitively when 
we're just outsiders is foolish.

Saturniia