[HPforGrownups] Rediscovering clues from ealier books WAS: Re: Dumbledore's pleading/

[Michell Thitathan]

No: HPFGUIDX 141511

Nora  wrote:
"The problem here is that JKR's idea of what things are unusual and thus marked and the fandom's ideas are radically divergent," 
and 
"I expect some things to be resolved and explained, but I suspect I 
expect more of it to stand as 'dude, just the way that things happen,"  <SNIP a lot> 


CH3ed replies: 
I agree! I think we over-analyze some themes too much (but then what else to do since we'll probably have to wait another 2 years or more for the final book to come out :( ).

I just love it when I go back and re-read the books and find the clues JKR had so stealthily placed in sometimes books in advanced (like the 'hand of glory' at that shop on knock-turn Alley...and on the same page Lucius Malfoy was selling 'poisons' (which he thought would implicate him if Arthur Weasley finds them at the Malfoy's, both of which turned up 4 books later in HBP). There are so much material in the HP series, and it is marvelously amazing to me how she uses most of it.