Characters and Consequences? ( Petunia)/ Snape's apologising to Harry

truthbeauty1 rh64643 at appstate.edu
Wed Oct 19 16:19:16 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141845

Lupinlore: 
> > > An apology will also be required of course, if only because 
> > > it would cost Sevvie so much to come up with it.

Betsy Hp:
> > I'm sorry, Harry, that I saved your life when Quirrell nearly 
> > killed you.  I'm sorry, Harry, that when Voldemort was invading 
> > your mind I tried to train you to keep him out.  
> > Hmmm, actually, I think Snape may well enjoy the whole 
> > apologizing 

Alla:
> Mine version of Snape apology will be much shorter and not tongue 
> in cheek. I am sorry Harry for giving a murderous maniac a reason 
> to kill your parents. I am sorry for helping you to grew up as an 
> orphan. I am really sorry that because of that you had to grew up 
> with Dursleys.
>
> See, I can grasp the idea of Snape redemption, I really, really 
> do and I even think that it may work well, but I absolutely cannot 
> grasp blaming Harry for looking at Snape in hateful way.


truthbeauty 1:

I agree 100%, Alla. Snape started this whole ball moving and if he 
is ever going to redeem himself and be of any use the cause, he is 
going to have to sincerely apologise for his past horrific actions. 
I personally believes he owes an apology to Neville and Hermione 
too, because of the way he has consistently mistreated them 
throuhgout the series, but I don't see that happening. I don't know 
how Snape will play out in the next book, but he has to make some 
ammends to Harry.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive