Snape and the blah-blah what happened on the tower....

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 141967

This is regarding snape's motives....whether or not DD is truly 
dead...Where snapes loyalties lie...And, why on earth DD never told 
Harry how his hand was harmed...

1.  The reason why DD never told Harry the story about his 
hand/arm...

Probably because DD is already dying...best to save it until the end 
of the lessons. It would be too much of a shock/outrage/new 
adventure for Harry.  DD NEEDS Harry to focus on the here and now
(defeating Voldemort), and upon his(DD's) particular lessons.

2.  Upon that nasty old tower....

Snape said the AK curse...but in reality Snape silently removed the 
effects of the "stopper in death" potions effects; hence the 
difference between all the AK's save for one no flash of green 
light/no cessation of movement etc.).

3.  If the stopper of death could be removed by a spell, then 
perhaps it may have been enhanced by one....(hence the quandry of 
snape's loyalties are still in the balance)..So, we may not know if 
Snape told dd about the UV, or if he did, what DD was asking him for 
on the tower.(my guess would be the saving route....seeing as we 
KNOW that DD planned to tell Harry a great deal more about 
everything in general...and Perhaps DD took Harry out with him that 
night because the only thing that DD thought would redeem Snape in 
Harry's eyes would be to save him--Dumbledore himself..It would 
explain the freezing of Harry to bear witness...we know it wasn't 
for anyones safety, at least, I do not believe so after DD told 
Harry, "I am not worried. I am with you.")

The cannon to support this..

1. DD told Harry he would explain about his hand later. (yet, did 
not) DD may be alot of things but he is not a liar.

2. We can see Snape healing Malfoy with spells...after a 
spell/curse..(we know that DD's hand was the result of a curse--
obtaining/destroying a ring.)

3. We know that Snape did some fast and furious work on the student 
that touched the necklace.(so I'm speculating the same may have 
happened after DD's injury to his hand after destroying the horcrux 
ring...)

4. Harry giving DD that drink from that nasty inferi lake may have 
removed any positive effects of the stopper in death...hence DD 
needed Snape! Or, the stopper of death may have been removed by 
drinking said potion...even more reason for Harry to get Dd to snape.
Irregardless for me I do not like Snape not so much because he AK'd 
Voldemort as much as, he set this whole chain of events in motion by 
telling moldy-voldie about the prophecy..

Sorry....just think Snape will pay heavily for creating seven books 
of turmoil...and hundreds dead and thousands if not millions placed 
in jeopardy due to his actions. (no wonder why he's so bitter to 
those who would recognize the error of his ways.)

The reason for the UV...because seldom is he who starts the 
turmoil...is ever the one to finish...Snapes mistake..hence the 
title..."Spinner's End".. The UV is Snapes undoing...(and I still 
would not be surprised if Wormtail put something in that wine he 
served!)

Also, perhaps because Wormtail told voldie what Snape had done..

I do believe Snape lied and told bella and cissy he knew what the 
orders were.

I also believe that Voldemort Truly wanted Draco to die.(If this is 
true...then Snape is in big trouble from Voldemort, as is Draco. 
Also, it means that Snape made a UV to protect Draco...when Voly 
meant him to die.

Is this what Snape realized on the tower? Is this why the look of 
revulsion?  Also, isn't this exactly the type of thing PP would do?

Which leads me to ask...did Wormtail spike Bella's, Cissy's and 
Snape's wine? Was this Wormtail's redemtion?

DeeDee