Snape and the blah-blah what happened on the tower....

B.G. hambtty at triad.rr.com
Sat Oct 22 15:54:11 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141971

> 
 I still would not be surprised if Wormtail put something in that 
wine he served!
> 
> Also, perhaps because Wormtail told voldie what Snape had done..
> 
> I do believe Snape lied and told bella and cissy he knew what the 
> orders were.
> 
> I also believe that Voldemort Truly wanted Draco to die.(If this 
is 
> true...then Snape is in big trouble from Voldemort, as is Draco. 
> Also, it means that Snape made a UV to protect Draco...when Voly 
> meant him to die.
> 
> Is this what Snape realized on the tower? Is this why the look of 
> revulsion?  Also, isn't this exactly the type of thing PP would do?
> 
> Which leads me to ask...did Wormtail spike Bella's, Cissy's and 
> Snape's wine? Was this Wormtail's redemtion?
> 
> DeeDee

BG writes:
I hadn't thought much about PP and the wine until this post.  
Interesting, what do you propose was in the drink, what did it do?  
We don't have enough information about any effects the wine had on 
the sisters.  If you are suggesting that the idea of the UV was 
conjured up from a potion in the wine, I believe that was Narsissa's 
intention from the start.  However, it is uncharacteristic of Snape 
to enter into such a binding contract without a complete 
understanding of his commitment.

Everyone still ponders - why did DD trust Snape?  There must be more 
than his coming to DD to confess that he told LV about the prophecy -
 Snape had no place to turn when LV vanished.  Did DD ask Snape to 
enter into a UV with him to protect Harry?  We saw how Snape was 
lured into one with Narsissa, it would be simple for DD to the same 
especially when Snape was at his most vulnerable.  This plot line 
would place Snape at the prophecy's introduction and its conclusion. 
Quote from DeeDee, "The reason for the UV...because seldom is he who 
starts the turmoil...is ever the one to finish...Snapes 
mistake..hence the title..."Spinner's End".. The UV is Snapes 
undoing...

Book 7
Harry will return to Hogwarts but not as a student.  He must use 
DD's pensieve to continue the lessons DD had planned.  Remember all 
the memories we saw in Book 6 were placed in tiny bottles and DD 
placed them into the pensieve.  Those are still there as far as we 
know.  Harry has much to learn from these memories.  More 
importantly, he must learn how to extract memories - especially his 
own.  He remembers the night his parents were murdered - he heard 
their voices (Dementors).  The Trio will enter that memory and many 
others to plan their defense against the Dark Arts.  Each will 
gather very different information from the memory.  We know they are 
stronger together than apart.  Hermione will bring her academic 
prowess.  She will research history, arithmancy, ancient runes and 
Horcruxes with help from Krum (you know Durmstrang's library has 
information on Horcruxes), Ron will use this information to plan 
strategies, Harry will lead the DA - the New Order.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive