Why Can't Harry and LV live while the other survives?

[curlyhornedsnorkack]

No: HPFGUIDX 142248

Snorky :
I know what the prophesy in Book 5 says, but I don't see any reason
why LV and Harry  can't go on living their separate lives. What in the
books, other than The prophesy, indicates that they can't?  Has JKR
given us any reasons so far? Neither one looks like he's going to drop
any limbs or curl up and die if he doesn't kill off the other.

(Sorry if this topic has been covered before, but I haven't noticed it.)


Quoting someone who quoted someone else they can't remember, "the line
""neither can live while the other survives"" might  mean that right
now, neither Harry nor LV are living to a full extent." How can we
tell that they aren't living to as full an extent as any other
character in the book?


I would greatly appreciate the favor of sticking to the books and to
logic to find your reasons. If you want to SPEW about something else,
please start up your own separate thread. Thanks!

Snorky