Depth? Things to take on their face value (Was: Sirius' loyalty)

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 139864


jen:
> > Unless Snape is not completely on Voldemort's side, and plans to 
> > use his superb Occlumency skills, he will be delivering every
plan  Dumbledore devised to Voldemort. 

Nora: 
> Assuming that Snape *knows* every plan Dumbledore devised.  I
submit  to you that we can't assume that, given the canonicity of
things going on that we saw that Dumbledore probably didn't tell 
Snape about.  (Unless, of course, he's lying to Harry about how 
many people  know all of the prophecy, or the horsepuckies.)

Pippin:
Snape knows that Dumbledore injured his hand retrieving a gold ring
with a black stone, and he is just as capable as Scrimgeour of
deducing that Harry was on top of the tower, and had accompanied 
Dumbledore on one of his mysterious disappearances.  Voldemort
already knows that Harry destroyed the Diary. He would hardly need to 
be told more.

Snape knows that Dumbledore had a Pensieve and that it may still
contain valuable memories, including the entire prophecy.

Snape knows that Ginny owes Harry her life and has been seen with
him quite a bit lately.

Pippin