Spinner's End--further evidence for DDsMan!Snape??
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Sep 12 01:24:57 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 140011
Julie wrote:
>
> I confess I can't think of any reason for Snape not to tell
Bellatrix that
> he delayed notifying the Order of Harry's suspected journey to the
DoM.
> If he's ESE! then he has no reason to keep it quiet. If he's DD's
Man,
> then he had no reason to delay notifying the Order in the first
place. I
> can only conclude that this time delay comes down to JKR's well-
known
> difficulties applying maths.
Potioncat:
Congratulations to Neri, the delay has almost become canon! The
thread about this has been my all time favorite, even though I
disagree with the "delay" conculsion.
DD says that Snape responded immediately and BADASS ALBUS it is.
Given that Patronuses are the method of communication, and they
appear to take some time to get from here to there and also appear to
be one-way and given that JKR has not always relied on scientific
charts for her data...I don't think Snape delayed.
Potioncat (who cannot remember how ALBUS breaks down, but the other
is Because Albus Dumbledore Says So....)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive