Spinner's End--further evidence for DDsMan!Snape??

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 140013

> 
> Potioncat:
> Congratulations to Neri, the delay has almost become canon! The 
> thread about this has been my all time favorite, even though I 
> disagree with the "delay" conculsion.

Alla:

Yes, I want to bow to Neri too and I DO agree with delay's 
conclusion. :-)


Potioncat: 
> DD says that Snape responded immediately and BADASS ALBUS it is. 

Alla:

Well, DD also says that Snape INTENDED to search the forest, he 
never says that Snape actually did, no?

"In the meantime he, professor Snape, intended to search the forest 
for you" - OOP, paperback, p.830.

I did found this quote to be suspicious prior to HBP, I find it 
doubly suspicious now.


> houyhnhnm:
<snip>
>> I think the supposed *delay* in notifying the Order is a very weak
> argument anyway for ESE!Snape. 


Alla:

Here is the link to Neri's post which, I think is in the middle of 
the thread, but sums up his argument perfectly.

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/108146


I think it is a very strong argument, but JMO of course.
 

JMO,

Alla