Hearing from the Great Middle & other assorted

houyhnhnm102 celizwh at intergate.com
Wed Sep 14 17:43:14 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140160

loonyloopy:

> Where is it in canon that Snape told the 
> Order Voldemort was after the prophecy in the DOM?

> Loony Loony, who needs this to be spelled out in 
> block letters as her 
> memory might be failing.

houyhnhnm:

Sometimes it's not where it is; it's where it's not--like the dog 
that didn't bark in the night.

DD has other spies--Lupin among the werewolves, Mundungus in the 
Wizarding underworld, but there is not any suggestion anywhere that 
he has another spy right next to Voldemort.  If such a whole cloth 
invention were to be proposed then it would be necessary to explain 
why DD risks his potion master by sending him back to LV.  And the 
whole issue of DD's trust of Snape would have to be revisited.

The Order has people standing guard over the prophecy in August.  
Where else could the information have come from?   






More information about the HPforGrownups archive