The AK itself, / Keep Harry Horcrux Free Challenge

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 140319


> > ibchawz:
> > 
> > Since hand bandages seem to be in short supply, I'll just grab the 
> > nearest lamp and prepare to repeated bash my head.  This one is 
> > relatively easy to work out.  The logical flow of events is as 
> > follows:
> > 
> > 1.  LV murders James Potter.
> > 2.  LV murders Lily Potter (Or rather Lily sacrifices herself as 
> > opposed to chosing to step aside).
> > 3.  LV attempts to murder Harry Potter, but the spell rebounds due 
> > to Lily's sacrifice.  
> > 
> > Harry would not have the scar at this point in time because LV has 
> > not attempted to murder him yet.  The scar is a by-product of the 
> > rebounded AK.
> 
> Saraquel:
> Preparing to bang head against desk thoroughly as well as iron hands 
> as this is my fourth post today!  Never mind it's gone midnight 
> here, so I'm off to bed in a mo.  In GoF Priori Incantatem, there is 
> no extra spell to account for the rebounded AK curse, implying that 
> Lily was AKed and died and Harry got his scar at one and the same 
> time.  Now do you see my problem?

Valky:
I am breaking an old agreement with Steve even going here, but I just
have to now this issue has come up again. Sorry :|

Okay I am going to speculate on why the wand order mistake existed in
the first place, IOW why would Lily be the last shadow out of the
wand. Yes I know it was corrected.. but if we can imagine a reason for
Lily to have been last.....

Okay, I mess with canon as we know it, I am ironing as we speak
believe me. But I can't help but think there was method to the madness
"originally". 

Logically what would that be? Could it be to conceal the spell that
occurred before Lily's death? The extenuating circumstance that made
her sacrifice that bit more powerful. 

Now if that was the case, by now JKR will have needed to change the
scene to suit the Priori Incantatem, IOW if there *was* a wand spell
from Voldemort prior to Lily's death, it couldn't be a wand spell
anymore, or alternately it could be arbitrarily moved to a place
behind James in the reverse order. However, it can still be a basis to
assume that there was always intended to be revealed an additional
magical incantation performed by Voldemort at Godrics Hollow in
addition to the AK's.

Valky 
Now locating a blunt object to beat her head with.