Draco and Narcissa in hiding (Was: Snape's future)
colebiancardi
muellem at bc.edu
Sat Sep 24 00:30:41 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 140682
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" <justcarol67 at y...>
wrote:
> At any rate, I agree with Potioncat that Draco's and Narcissa's deaths
> may well be faked in Book 7 and I think both DD's little speech and
> the Draught of Living Death are hints as to how it might be brought
> about. It seems to me as if both Snape and the Order would have to be
> involved in some way to pull it off, and that Harry would recognize
> this act of mercy (unmerited by definition) as Dumbledore's will.
>
> Carol, noting that the idea is not a theory but wondering if anyone
> thinks it has merit
I think it has merit as well, except I don't think it is the Draught
of Living Death(more on that later). I think DD was going to do some
spell or potion(hence Snape's involvment) to make the Malfoy family
*die*, when in fact they were alive and unhappy, protected by the
Filelius Charm. I think that this is what happened to Regulus Black(I
am in the camp that he is not dead, but the original "You cannot be
killed if you are already dead" wizard). This goes back to my Snape
theory on why DD trusts him and that Snape delivered Regulus to DD,
instead of killing him on LV's orders. I think that Regulus will
play a huge part in book 7 - since Rowling isn't going to introduce
any new characters, he would be a good bet, IMHO.
OK - the Draught of Living Death - I think that potion is not used to
*hide* the living and make them seem dead. Instead of I think that
potion is used keep someone, who is moments away from death, from
actually crossing over to the other side. I think that is what DD had
been taking during book 6 and why Snape didn't really kill DD - he
just released him from the effects of the potion. DD doesn't fear
death, as he has stated time & time again, but he needed to teach
Harry about Horcruxes before he could go.
but that is just my theory. Are we hoping it is just 1 year & 9
months, or do we think Rowling will keeps us hanging for a longer
period of time?
colebiancardi
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive