Who is RAB again (WAS: Re: Snape and Regulus/OFH!Snape)

deborahhbbrd hubbada at unisa.ac.za
Wed Sep 28 07:03:04 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140847

jajaredor, on the Subject of: Who is RAB again (WAS: Re: Snape and
Regulus/OFH!Snape), suggests that:

< I remember reading once that in deutsch, black is zwarts but this
hasn't been proved yet because I don't have a copy of the book in
deutsch version. so if RAB is really Regulus then the initials in the
deutsch version would be RAZ. (This, in support of the RAB = Regulus
Arcturus Black theory).>

Deborah, now:

Good thinking, just mildly flawed ... ! On a technicality, and to
minimise hopeless quests, Deutsch = German, where black, or Black, is
Schwartz. RAS, therefore ... As it would also be in Afrikaans.
However, in Dutch the initials would certainly be RAZ. Three fruitful
fields for research! Are these translations out yet? 

After all, wasn't it the Portuguese translator who had to know the sex
of Prof Sinistra, and thus clarified for all of us that she's a she?

Any language which didn't use the B initial for the Blacks would do,
in fact - what fun! Polyglots of the Potterverse, unite! You have
nothing to lose but your speculations!

Deborah, frustrated not to have access to any translations right now









More information about the HPforGrownups archive