Werewolf Bites

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 28 13:48:32 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140849

 Dave:
> While rereading SS, Chapter 13 "Nicholas Flamel," I found the 
following in the last paragraph on p 220 of my US edition:
>  
> "The next morning in Defense against the Dark Arts, while copying 
down different ways of treating werewolf bites, Harry and Ron were 
still discussing ...." 
>  
> If first year students are taught several treatment methods, why is 
everyone so afraid of Grayback and why is everyone so concerned and 
worried about Bill Weasley's injuries?
>  
> Is the preceding a Flint?   Comments anyone.

Finwitch:

Not really -- treating werewolf bites is quite different from curing 
the 'furry little problem.' The biggest problem was not the wound - it 
was the fact that Bill *might* be a werewolf. (All those nasty 
prejudices -- but not wholly without reason, considering that Fenrir 
Greyback).

Also, although I think that ointment was helpful, there are other ways, 
such as phoenix tears (they DO have healing powers - enough to 
completely cure a *basilisk* bite, and I'd say that's more lethal). Too 
bad Fawkes was singing his lament at the time and unavailable.

Oh - you know, I think phoenix tears *could* heal poisoning, too. You 
just need a bleeding wound so the tears go directly into your blood... 
bezoar is less messy, but maybe it doesn't work on basilisk venom. 
Phoenix tears DO, however.

Finwitch






More information about the HPforGrownups archive