Political positions of the characters
Joe Goodwin
joegoodwin1067 at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 3 23:46:39 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150476
a_svirn:
What do you mean by affected? That they were more inclined to
violence than most, because of the war? I think you have no
authority to make this statement either. There is nothing in canon
to suggest that. And, you know, no one is more affected by the war
than Harry, but we don't see him being *vigilante*, do we?
Joe:
Yes we do, he goes to the Ministry instead of relying on Magical Law Enforcement to handle the situation. In fact the entire Order of the Phoenix are vigilantes. They are taking the law into their own hands. Which just goes to illustrate the truth, you can be the good guys AND be vigilantes.
The truth is we no almost nothing about the Marauders/Snape feud so mostly what we believe is colored by our perceptions of their characters. Some people want Snape to be good and some people want Snape to bad.
Joe
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive