[HPforGrownups] Re: R.A.B

[Jazmyn Concolor]

No: HPFGUIDX 150484



gelite67 wrote:

>As Geoff so dramatically pointed out :), this has been discussed 
>before.  I personally think RAB is alive, though -- they never found 
>his body as I recall.
>
>Here's a wild RAB theory for you, partially intended to be tongue-in-
>cheek.  One of the Horcruxes is locked up at Gringotts, where else?  
>RAB discovered the location, attempted to break in and got sucked in 
>the vault fewer than ten years ago, b/c they check the vaults every ten 
>years.  He's survived all this time b/c he had his wand and he managed 
>to destroy the Horcrux.  Wonder when the next vault check is due?  :)
>
>  
>
I have a different theory.  Regalus drank the same potion that 
Dumbledore later drank to get to the real horcrux and died from it and 
people simply assumed that Voldemort killed him.   Its not like anyone 
would dare ASK Voldemort 'did you kill Regalus Black?'....  I don't 
think even Snape would dare ask such questions directly...   This is why 
I feel that Dumbledore was going to die from the poison/potion he drank 
in the cave, he knew he would die from it after seeing the note left 
behind by RAB and all Snape did later was put him out of his misery at 
his request. He likely even suspected that Voldemort would make 
acquiring the Horcrux deadly to anyone who went after.  Unlikely that 
Volde would ever have to go get it himself, being as there was no need 
once it was hidden.  It was mentioned before that there ARE poisons that 
there are no antidotes for.

Jazmyn