Requiescat in Pace, My Dark Phoenix

[Jeanette]

No: HPFGUIDX 151333

 I think the orignal post was brilliantly thought out and have enjoyed 
the answering posts.  The case for switched DD/SS is compelling but I 
do have a problem.  

  I thought the AK curse not only had to be said, but truly meant with 
the deepest, darkest urge to kill.  It is hard to see DD saying that 
curse with murderous hatred to kill Snape who he trusts, and if indeed 
it all has been planned, who is laying down his life to save the whole 
wizarding world.

Jeanette