Mean Sirius? (was Scene with likeable James WAS: Re: Eileen Pince)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 156286

> > Alla:
> > 
> > Erm... I am confused. Sirius disliked Molly and Ron or Molly and 
Ron 
> > disliked him? What canon support do you have for that, if you 
don't 
> > mind?
> 
> zgirnius:
> I think I know to what Irene is referring.
> 
> In PoA Sirius breaks Ron's leg and disarms him. So I think it is 
fair 
> to say he is not acting in a likable way towards Ron. Was this 
truly 
> unavoidable? Or did Sirius simply not care, because while he was 
an 
> innocent bystander, Ron was not one of Sirius's friends?

Alla:

Yeah, that is what I thought too, but no, **simply not cared** is 
not how I would describe Sirius state after Azkaban . More like half 
insane and focused on killing Pettigrew, IMO.

And Ron did not become one of Sirius friends either when he send him 
an owl to keep, IMO. But I suppose by then Ron became a member of 
his pack? :)

I am getting more and more curious how one becomes the member of the 
Sirius' and James pack, because honestly it looks to me that all the 
members of the order and kids were **members of Sirius pack** as in 
he cared for them ( had arguments, but IMO cared for them) and was 
ready to die for them.

I mean which one of the good guys was **not** the member of Sirius' 
pack, except Snape ( if he is a good guy, hehe).


Zgirnius: 
> I'm not sure how much Peter liked adult James (he certainly did 
not act 
> like he did).
>

Alla:

I am not sure we can say whether Peter liked James or not, I mean 
one can betray out of fear and cowardice and still don't hate the 
person. IMO.

But sure that I buy, it is highly likely that Peter is the person 
who did not like adult James and Lily and Harry and Dumbledore. That 
does not seem to me to be the testimony against all those people 
characters though, Peter dislike of them, I mean. IMO of course.