Eileen Prince & Grandma Longbottom

[abergoat]

No: HPFGUIDX 156492


Carol wrote:
> Carol, who used to think that the dog-faced woman (Agnes) was Snape's
> mother and that her wicked husband cursed her, but JKR has thrown
> Vanishing Potion on that speculation by making Tobias a Muggle and
> giving the two women different first names

Abergoat asks:
But why give up on the idea that dog-faced woman is Snape's mother? I
think Voldemort transforming her has excellent possibilities. Why is
it that Dumbledore couldn't give any information Ravenclaw Horcrux
(ignoring the idea that it could have been a Gryffindor item) but
could on everything else? And JKR has told us that Harry knows more
than he thinks he does. And JKR very clearly showed that Voldemort
doesn't always kill horcrux victims (Morfin Gaunt). Eileen as the
holder of the Ravenclaw relic tidies up many things.

Abergoat