Eileen Prince & Grandma Longbottom

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Sat Aug 5 03:36:15 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 156535

 
> Abergoat asks:
> But why give up on the idea that dog-faced woman is Snape's mother? I
> think Voldemort transforming her has excellent possibilities. Why is
> it that Dumbledore couldn't give any information Ravenclaw Horcrux
> (ignoring the idea that it could have been a Gryffindor item) but
> could on everything else? And JKR has told us that Harry knows more
> than he thinks he does. And JKR very clearly showed that Voldemort
> doesn't always kill horcrux victims (Morfin Gaunt). Eileen as the
> holder of the Ravenclaw relic tidies up many things.


Potioncat:
Because Agnes is not the same name as Eileen. Agnes's son comes to 
visit. (whoever he is) It is not Eileen. Now, if we'd never been given 
her name, it would be different. Now, maybe Agnes is Lupin's mother???

It's very fun to speculate. One of my speculations is that Muggle born 
Lily and Son of a Muggle Severus may have met off campus, or may have 
met at Diagon Alley. But that is speculation, no canon for it. Your 
Eileen as holder of a Ravenclaw relic is also speculation. It's 
interesting, but it's hard to have a real opinion, because there just 
isn't any canon to tie it to.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive