Voldemort's Plan (Was RE Good Reasons for DD to die)

[spookedook]

No: HPFGUIDX 156732

Carol earlier:
What I don't understand, though, is how making an Unbreakable Vow
could be regarded as "the ultimate gift" or why you think that DD
would wish him to make one. Surely DD wouldn't compel him against
his will.

> SNIP
Carol, still confused about how a UV could be a "gift" and hoping
that katssirius will clarify her position


 Brothergib

<<huge snip>>

It always seemed strange to me that LV  would let Snape know that
Draco was involved in a plan to kill DD. I  don't think LV
completely trusts Snape as yet (which is why he has  Wormtail spying
on him) so why would he risk prewarning DD. If this is  the case

Tinktonks:

I think that LV is being very calculating here. He doesn't care
about any of his followers in the slightest. They are pawns and they
are expendable. Dumbledore however is a real challenger.

Draco is just a boy, he has nothing of noteworthy value to LV that
he can't get elsewhere. If Draco dies so be it, if he succeeds he
proves himself valuable and LV will have a new and valuable tool.
Nothing to lose.

Snape is more tricky to LV, he must be aware Snape is a very
accomplished Occlumens to be either fooling DD, Himself or even
both! This makes him a questionable ally. LV also knows DD, when LV
enters DD's office for a job DD knows he is a murderer (Speculation
I know but I'm pretty sure of it) but he lets LV leave without
resistance or reprimand. DD  could have attempted to destroy LV
there and then (most would say it would have been a service to
mankind) yet he did not. DD is too noble to attack unprovoked, even
if LV had attempted to murder him through someone else.

Using this logic (which some may think is flawed!) if Snape is a
traitor then he dies, as does Draco but this is no loss to LV, and
there is no real risk of DD finding out about the attempt on his
life. DD is very wise and is almost certain to know that LV will
attempt to kill him, LV knows this!

If Snape is loyal to LV then he gets rid of the biggest thorn in his
side with no consequences.

Sounds like a smart plan to me!!! Win win situation for LV! No harm
in telling Snape the plan as he will either prove himself or die!

Tinktonks