Spinner's End
Ceridwen
ceridwennight at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 10 10:32:44 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 156766
houyhnhnm:
> I'm not sure that the "Snape" was a polyjuiced impostor. I can't
begin to imagine who it would be, if not Snape.
Ceridwen:
Okay, I'm answering twice to the same post. I just had another
thought on who might be Polyjuiced, though I still don't think this
person was fleeing Hogwarts in Flight of the Prince.
What if LV himself was Polyjuiced to look like someone in only one
scene? Yes, I could see him on the tower; I can't see him on the
lawn, and the problem of switching places intrudes. I can't see him
as Tonks - Harry's scar would have hurt, wouldn't it? Even if not, I
just can't see that. Not LV, he would have rather killed Tonks and
Harry, I think, and The Battle for the WW would have started in HBP.
After all, LV would have been right there in Hogwarts...
So, when and where would LV have been Polyjuiced? If at all, then at
Spinner's End. Still doesn't read quite right for the Snape of
Spinner's End to be LV, but I think it would be more in his style to
try and trap followers into revealing treacherous ways than to sneak
around Hogwarts. The other shoe didn't drop, neither Bellatrix nor
Narcissa are reported dead or tortured after this.
But, since I do agree that someone was Polyjuiced as someone else,
why not consider LV as a possible Polyjuiced Someone?
Ceridwen.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive