Spinner's End

[sallyaltass]

No: HPFGUIDX 156770

>
> Ceridwen: (snipped)
>
> What if LV himself was Polyjuiced to look like someone in only one
> scene?  Yes, I could see him on the tower; I can't see him on the
> lawn, and the problem of switching places intrudes.  I can't see
him
> as Tonks - Harry's scar would have hurt, wouldn't it?
> So, when and where would LV have been Polyjuiced?  If at all, then
at
> Spinner's End.  Still doesn't read quite right for the Snape of
> Spinner's End to be LV, but I think it would be more in his style
to
> try and trap followers into revealing treacherous ways than to
sneak
> around Hogwarts.  The other shoe didn't drop, neither Bellatrix
nor
> Narcissa are reported dead or tortured after this.
>
> But, since I do agree that someone was Polyjuiced as someone else,
> why not consider LV as a possible Polyjuiced Someone?
>

I believe that this is a really interesting idea.  IMO Snape is not
polyjuiced and swapped, and his motives for killing Dumbledore in
the tower are purely because of theUV he made with Narcissa re
Draco, Draco could not carry out the 'job' he was recruited for by
LV, and so Snape had to carry out the 'job' or be killed himself.

As for LV being the polyjuiced one, I agree that it is a posibility
that he was at Spinners End with Bella, Snape and Narcissa.  IMO LV
was Wormtail, and as everyone with few exceptions believe that
Wormtail is dead, then no one be any wiser.  We never actually meet
LV in HBP, and Wormtails actions at Snape's home is slightly out of
character, and is more argumentative with Snape.  He is clearly
disgusted of Snape's attitude to him, and when he comments that he
can speak to LV himself if he so wishes could be a more sinister
remark that Snape doesn't pick up on.  Also Wormtail constantly
avoids Snape's eyes, and even though LV is an excellent Occulamens,
so is Snape, and as Wormtail was supposed to be 'talentless', Snape
would become suspicious if he could tell that Wormtail was hiding
things through legimency.

I apologise if this argument has been made before, but I am new to
the posting board.  I am very passionate about HP and am constantly
reading and cross-referencing the book.

Sally