Question on Snape:

[Robert Allen]

No: HPFGUIDX 156779

Sally:
> IMO Snape is not polyjuiced and swapped, and his motives for 
> killing Dumbledore in the tower are purely because of the UV 
> he made with Narcissa re Draco, Draco could not carry out the 
> 'job' he was recruited for by LV, and so Snape had to carry 
> out the 'job' or be killed himself.
> <snip>


Robert:
If Snape is evil why, at the end of HBP did JK write that his face 
was twisted as if he was in as much pain as the howling dog? 
   
The bad guys like killing and destruction...and as far as we can 
tell the bad guys won at the end of HBP...so why would Snape be "in 
pain..."
   
Everyone just needs to come to terms with the fact that he is 
essentially good...