Killing Dumbledore

Kemper iam.kemper at gmail.com
Fri Aug 18 05:38:06 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 157108

Kemper:

I've been out for a few weeks.  Since then my brother and I had been
discussing the JKR interview.  He made an interesting suggestion based
on Snape being good (Rushdie's opinion being correct) and that
Dumbledore is dead.

Assumtion: Dumbledore is dead because Snape had to kill him.

If that's so: Snape now has the potential to make a Horcrux, if he
hasn't already.

This leaves leads to new outcomes for previously expressed scenarios:
LV 'kills' Snape for seeking/destroying LV's Horcruxes, or Snape
'sacrifices' self for Harry.

Other questions:
Does one become evil if he separates his soul?
Is there a spell that can reunite separated soul pieces?
If so, and if a person is evil for separating his soul, does person
revert back to his previous 'goodness' (or 'not-as-badness').


Sorry for any randomness.

Kemper, accepting that Dumbledore is dead




More information about the HPforGrownups archive