[HPforGrownups] Re: Moaning Myrtle---Muggleborn?

[Jordan Abel]

No: HPFGUIDX 157211

> Abergoat adds:
> I'm not sure Myrtle's story is quite over. I'm suspicious that someone
> else has talked to Myrtle about how she died, and that someone is why
> Hagrid wasn't completely expelled but allowed to stay on at school.
> (Unfortunately Myrtle herself tells us that she ran off to haunt Olive
> Hornby. So this someone couldn't have a professor talk directly with
> her informant, Myrtle. My guess is that by the time Myrtle returned to
> Hogwarts it was too late so Dumbledore was only able to cast enough
> doubt to allow Hagrid to stay on, but not as a student.)

Random832:
But he _was_ guilty of something, that it's arguable was worthy of
expulsion even _without_ having caused a death. Keep in mind that even
after he was proven innocent beyond all doubt of any involvement in
Myrtle's death or of opening the CoS, he still didn't get the right to
use a wand. Raising an acromantula inside the castle, which no-one
disputes he did, still constitutes reckless endangerment.