Moaning Myrtle---Muggleborn?

abergoat adescour at pirl.lpl.arizona.edu
Mon Aug 21 04:05:24 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 157218


Random832 wrote:
> But he _was_ guilty of something, that it's arguable was worthy of
> expulsion even _without_ having caused a death. Keep in mind that even
> after he was proven innocent beyond all doubt of any involvement in
> Myrtle's death or of opening the CoS, he still didn't get the right to
> use a wand. Raising an acromantula inside the castle, which no-one
> disputes he did, still constitutes reckless endangerment.

Abergoat responds:
But did Hagrid ever get cleared? I believe Fudge takes him away in
Chamber of Secrets once the trouble starts again. And we don't know
how long Myrtle haunted Olive Hornby, it could have been years.

Abergoat








More information about the HPforGrownups archive