Dueling and Honorariums...
Robert Allen
robertpatrickallen at yahoo.com
Mon Aug 28 19:31:05 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 157545
> Mike:
> > > The AK is unblockable; unless you stick a statue in front
> > > of it, but there's no countercurse; unless you know how to
> > > invoke ancient magic.
>
> Random832:
> > Is there even then? Not a single person in a position to
> > actually know (which list is very short indeed) has actually
> > come out and SAID that the spell that was cast that night was
> > the AK. Several Harry-is-a-horcrux theories rest on the idea
> > that it was not.\
>
> Mike:
> Quite true. I myself questioned how DD knew that the curse LV
> used was an AK, but he certainly seemed unequivocal pronouncing
> Harry's scar the result of an AK. <shrug> I guess we have to take
> his word for it, at least at this point in the story.
Robert:
This SHOULD solve it:
from "Goblet of Fire" American, page 652...
"You all know that on the night I lost my powers and my body, I
tried to kill him." -Voldi
If we take his word for it and we probably should, he was trying
to kill Harry. Probably with AK....wich as far as we know is the
only "killing curse." Harry is a Horcrux is pretty lame in the grand
scheme of things...too easy to predict...
And again...Voldemort tries to kil Harry in the graveyard with
AK. The secret to all this is probably going to be something we
just can't predict. No one, really, could have figured out the
whole Horcrux thing until they read book six. General ideas I am
sure popped up but not anything on the nose. So it will be with
book 7, I think.
Robert
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive