LV's Wand question

Annemehr annemehr at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 5 04:53:42 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 162396


> Annemehr wrote:
> > So, I figure, Wormtail had LV's wand hidden in his robes when he 
> > staged his own death and framed Sirius (I mean the robes he was 
> > wearing, not the bloodied ones he left at the scene along with 
his 
> > finger for the Ministry to find).  Then the wand was safely on 
his 
> > person all the years he spent in rat form with the Weasleys, 
until 
> > the day he met up with LV in Albania.  Safest place for it, 
really.


> Carol responded:
<snip> 
> I don't think, however, that he had a wand with him, either his own 
or
> Voldemort's, when he transformed into a rat and disappeared after
> killing the twelve Muggles. Otherwise, he would have had a wand with
> him and been able to defend himself in the Shrieking Shack.<snip>

Annemehr:
Well...

I agree with your guess (snipped) that Wormatail left his own wand 
behind in the blasted street.  But I don't think it's impossible to 
believe that he had LV's wand with him in the Shrieking Shack.

After all, he was facing five armed people at the time (Sirius having 
taken Snape's wand from the bed), and I bet he didn't like his 
chances in a duel.  Instead, he took a calculated risk and went with 
the begging.

Besides, it makes him such a grotesque parody of Lily, facing death, 
declining to draw a wand, and pleading for a life to be spared.  I 
love it.

Annemehr
who does have odd tastes





More information about the HPforGrownups archive