Harry and Draco WAS: Re: The Train Scene GoF / Draco's Crying (long)
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Dec 10 00:59:43 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 162590
Kathyk:
> Draco gets no sympathy from me due to his calling Hermione a
> Mudblood. Harry has less tolerance for bullying at school because
he
> has to put up with Dudley at home. The adults in Harry's life do
him
> no favors because they do nothing to stop the abuse. When kids are
> left to handle bullies the results can be less than ideal.
Alla:
This is general comment of the sort, not directly replying to you,
since I agree with you,but I thought that would be good enough place
to put it, since I got a bit lost trying to find direct quotations I
was thinking of.
I keep reading this thread and getting more and more surprised from
the analogies of Harry behaving like James towards Draco, etc.
>From several posts I got the impressions that in the initial
confrontation between them Harry misperceived Draco's intentions,
etc. I mean, really from the moment they met Draco insulted **the
other kind ** of witches and wizards and lo and behold this is the
kind of witch Harry's mom was. And of course afterwards Draco
manages to insult Harry's first friend.
But even his insult of Ron falls behind Draco insulting muggleborn
witches and wizards to me.
What else is that if not confrontation?
Of course maybe in Draco's head he wanted to become friends with
Harry, I cannot pretend to know what was in his head at that time,
but even if he did, he revealed what he stands for to Harry.
I am not surprised at all that Harry did not want to be friends with
the bigot, I really don't.
Harry probably already started to learn that Draco has a human side
to him, but I completely disagree as I always do that Harry
misinterpreted the part of Draco's personality that Draco revealed
to him earlier.
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive