Is Bella a killer? WAS:,Re: Could Deathly Hallows

[lone_white_werewolf]

No: HPFGUIDX 163250

>
 Jeremiah Wrote
> I think it has more to dowith the character of Ballatrix than
anything else.
Or, is she really a killer? She is a torturer, as
> we know, but killing someone is much greater in the HP world.


> But to get back to your origional question: I think having Sirius
die from
> an accident is much more tragic. it's one of those: "And... Opps!
he's dead"
> moments that come at you. If we had a "flash of green light" or read the
> curse as bellatrix said it then it would have been way too
simplistic. Plus,
> that veil leaves us some gaping holes as far as what the nature of the
> Department of Mysteries really is all about.



Wouldn't driving someone to insanity be worse then killing them, in a
sense?  They would be in a prolonged state of suffering.  If she is
willing to do that then surely it is only a matter of time before she
takes the next step to killing.

I don't think Sirius going through the veil is just a pure accident.
If it was there are hundreds of ways J.K could have had him die
without him going through the veil.

lone_white_werewolf