Role of ESE in Hero's Quest (was:Re: Was HPB's ending BANG-y?...)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 147575

> > Alla:
> > 
> > Harry knows "from the get go" of book 7 who the villains are 
> > and Snape can very well be amongst villains. Basically, in the 
book 
> > 7 IMO Harry will not make mistakes as to who the villains are.
> > 
> Renee:
> But does he? I'd say that as long as Snape remains ambiguous, he 
can't
> be entirely sure. That he believes Snape is a villain doesn't mean
> it's true.
>

Alla:

True, true, I was just talking about the applicability of the rules 
of the Quest to the outcome which I see as most desirable, but as I 
said in another thread, I can see Snape turning out to be DD!M ( it 
is just then I have to twist Dumbledore character as I see him now 
in my head a lot), but of course it is a viable possibility.

Harry's belief does not mean that it is true, but I see it as a 
viable possibility too.

I see Harry in book 7 not as an idiot child, but as a Hero in the 
journey. IMO his major challenge towards Snape would be learning to 
forgive him for his very real crimes, NOT discover that he was wrong 
about Snape.... again.

But the fact that I believe it does not mean that it is true, as I 
said I can see Snape as loyal to Dumbledore, because of ambiguity we 
were given.

JMO,

Alla