Snape Loved Lily, now with Secret Keeper switch

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 148621

> Sydney:
> 
> If he wasn't quite trusting
> Sirius as SK, it's hard to see how he'd be comfortable with a SK
> proposed by Sirius either. (And, by the way, just what WAS Sirius'
> cunning plan?  If the secret can't be extorted or tortured out, and 
it
> dies with the Keeper, then why bother with the switch?  Either JKR 
or
> Sirius wasn't firing on all cylinders on this one.. ).

zgirnius:
Do we know it can't be extorted or tortured out? (AM I missing some 
explanation of this?)

Or are you just saying that Sirius would assume this to be the case, 
were he the Secret Keeper?

Sydney:
> I have no difficulty
> picturing Snape storming around like a lunatic about yelling OMG ARE
> YOU PEOPLE BLIND SIRIUS IS EVIL!!!  heh-- just like Harry about 
Snape.

zgirnius:
ROTFL.
Dumbledore must wonder if it is catching...

--zgirnius now signs off for the day, as she is unsure where her iron 
even IS...