Secret Keepers/JKR Poll Question - Confussion

h2so3f h2so3f at yahoo.com
Thu Feb 23 06:52:35 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 148653

CH3ed:
I agree with Allies' and Steve's take on the nature of the FC. If 
the secret was the location of 'the Potters', then perhaps the 
secret ceased to be when both Lily and James died and there was only 
1 Potter left (singular and no longer a family). Then there was no 
need for the location to be destroyed. The Potters no longer existed.

Also I agree with the view that it was DD's FC that caused Harry to 
not be able to see 12GP while it was the HQ of the OotP. Unplottable 
charm seem to work more with muggles like in Hogwarts (which only 
magical people can see, muggles only see an unstable ruin). Sirius 
mentioned that he didn't think any 'muggles' would want to come and 
call on his house anyway when he was telling Harry of the protective 
charms. 

Lupinlore mentioned a solution on another thread, but I don't think 
it works. He said that Harry could just blind-fold the Dursleys when 
he leads them into 12GP, but I don't think the Dursleys would be 
able to get in the place (as long as it is still the HQ of the OotP 
and; therefore, protected by the FC still) regardless of whether 
they're able to see it or not. 

CH3ed  :O)








More information about the HPforGrownups archive