Special treatment - yes or no

[chewbacca98407]

No: HPFGUIDX 146004

Magpie <belviso at a...> wrote:
> No, I emphasized that they had officially won the contest 
> (which is why the banners are hanging), and that the winning 
> was fair because they won. 
> There's no subplot about a fixed house contest suddenly being 
> made fair.  I said "for whatever reason" meaning that we were 
> not told how every single point was given out during the year, 
> not to suggest that they bought their points on the black market 
> or some other cheating way.  It's not just not fair because it's 
> not Gryffindor or because it is Slytherin.  Did they break into 
> the hourglass and switch the jewels?  Blackmail teachers?  
> 
> The Slytherins don't seem at all aware that they've earned their 
> lead unfairly that I remember, especially throught he actions of 
> Draco Malfoy. 


Chewie now:
  Do you not think that if the points in the end of term feast, 
awarded to the Gryfs., were given out prior to the end of term that 
some teacher *caugh- SNAPE -caugh* would have found a way to take 
them away again? Come on, we have all been reading the same books 
and the above seems like a no-brainer to me.
Sorry if this seems harsh, but come on...please.  They had to be 
awarded at the very end.  It was not a slight to the Slytherins, it 
was a jab at Snape. Imo of course.  It has nothing to do with the 
points being awarded fairly throughout the year or not.  They may 
have been, or may not.  It does not matter.