ESE! Snape or not WAS: Re: Cheating

[Amanda Shoffner]

No: HPFGUIDX 146324

Nicky Joe:
<SNIP>
I used to think good ole' Snapey was ESE! but now I gotta wonder.  
Also, did anyone notice in HBP that when Snape was talking to 
Narcissa about Draco that Snape said, "I happen to know about Draco's mission."  However, no one ever actually mentioned what Draco's mission was.  Did Snape REALLY know?  Or was he just pulling Bella's chain and got in a bit over his head when Narcissa asked for the UV?

Amanda:
   
  IMO: I do not think that Snape is ESE. Of all the wizards, DD is the one whose word I would trust the most. I believe he would take care in taking an 'ex-Death Eater' under his wing. If SS used occlumency, DD would know. DD can tell when a memory has been modified/etc. In addition, in every book, we see SS comming to the aid of Harry/DD. 
   
  (all hardcover, US version)
   
  1. SS/PS - Countercurse on Quirrell's magic on HP during the game. Helping DD protect the stone with potions obstacle.
  2. CoS - HP used SS's potions for making 'polyjuice' potion.
  3. PoA - Standing in front of HP/RW/HG putting himself at risk of werewolf!Lupin. I have always found it interestin how SS just happened to be in the area HP was in to catch him wondering the HUGE castle at night, Lupin right behind him
  4. GoF - Was right beside DD and ready for helping when HP was with Moody!CrouchJr. with truth potion ready.
  5. OoP - Continually giving the Order information on LV.
  6. HBP - Why woud SS have an argument w/ DD at the edge of the forbidden forest saying 'I want out'. I strongly believe that SS told DD about the UV and did not want to have to go through with it and was arguing with DD on what to do. He is continually trying to get information from Draco as to what he is doing.
  7. ??? - ***IMO***: SS and HP will have a run in, and HP will be suprised at the outcome
   
  Let me know what you think, or if I missed any of SS's signs of ESE/DM (Dumbledore's Man)
   
  ~Amanda~Trying to make sense of everything