Voldemort "intentionally" makes Harry a Horcrux?

[Goddlefrood]

No: HPFGUIDX 146359

> dobbyisdumbledore wrote:
<SNIP>
> So what goes wrong? Voldmort (and followers?) go to Godric's
Hallow
> (the Potter's hiding place) and kills James (the murder sufficent
for
> creating the Horcrux. He then places the Horcrux in Harry.
<SNIP>

Having read and absorbed your theory I have to say it is rather
unlikely. It falls down simply on only the following point, and if
this question can be satisfactorily answered then my view might be
modified.

The question is "Why would Lily allow Voldemort to place a Horcrux
in Harry?". I am assuming that Lily knows the implications of a
Horcrux residing in her son by posing this.

It would also have to be accepted that Lily left Harry alone for 
some time while she knew the family was under attack, which is 
inordinately improbable.

The original theory for those who have not fully read it assumes
that LV kills James, places a Horcrux in Harry, allows Lily to live
and then kills Harry.

Goddlefrood