Voldemort "intentionally" makes Harry a Horcrux?

Amanda Shoffner babyhrndz at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 13 01:31:00 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146380

Amanda:
I have had thoughts on this as well. Yet I came to the conclusion 
that the prophecy goes against it. The prophecy states that one 
will have to kill the other, and one cannot live while the other 
survives. If it is LV that cannot live while HP survives, that 
would mean that LV would have to kill a piece of his own soul, 
which he has been using to ensure his 'immortality'. On the other 
hand if it is HP that cannot live while the other survives, then 
if HP lives, LV will not die as his soul is in HP as a horcrux. 
If LV was to make HP a horcrux, that would be a waste of his soul 
since right afterwards he tries to kill HP.
   
  I had a convo w/ some HP fan friends of mine on this one when I 
thought of this possibility. But then again, JKR could make that 
the twist of fate at the end. What do you think?
   
  ~Amanda








More information about the HPforGrownups archive