ESE! Snape or not (Was: Re: Cheating)

[Amanda Shoffner]

No: HPFGUIDX 146376

  Amanda:
  The main reason I like HP4GU is this, getting ideas and insight 
from others about things I have and have not thought up yet.
   
  Alla- I agree with you, SS values DD’s protection. Yet SS chose 
to help out HP when he didn’t have to. Neri has a good theory 
about SS&JP LD. Having the Life Debt along with telling LV about 
the first half of the prophesy ultimately having a hand in LP&JP’s 
death, should the LD have kicked in at that time? Yet one can 
argue that SS did not know that it was the Potters the prophesy 
was about. I don’t know. Yet DD might have told SS the LD is now 
for HP. That would be reason for DD to tell HP that HP has no 
reason to doubt SS. For someone 
   
  Carol-In answer to your question, ESE means SS is for LV. In 
regards to the movie point of reference, IMO seeing that JKR is 
overseeing the production of the movies, I think she would let 
the director know if that would/wouldn’t be characteristic of SS 
and make sure that everything goes along with her books.
   
  Thanks for the input and helping bring to light more ideas and 
facts.
   
  So much speculation and so little answers to the riddles. I 
hope time has a broom to fly on because the suspense is putting 
a killing curse on my patience. Lol
   
  ~Amanda – hoping not to be disappointed and find a (DDM)! Snape.