Harry Vanquishing LV without killing him.

kelleyaynn kelleyaynn at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 13 17:34:09 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 146402

  
>   Luckdragon:
>   Before his powers and his supporters LV was simply Tom Riddle. 
If LV were to lose either his magical ability or if everyone turned 
on him in unity and no longer feared him he would again become Tom 
Riddle. This way LV is "vanquished" without dying, and because Harry 
would be behind this either by reducing LV's powers through the 
destruction of the horcruxes or by convincing all of the magical 
community to turn against LV then the prophecy is met. LV would be 
dead, Tom Riddle would be a muggle ,if he doesn't end his own life, 
and Harry could get on with Life. Does this make sense.
> 
>

Kelleyann:

But the prophecy doesn't say Harry only has to "vanquish" Voldemort. 
The prophecy says "either must DIE (emphasis mine) at the hand of 
the other." It also says only one can live. So getting rid of 
Voldemorts powers isn't killing him. 

I would like to see Harry not kill LV, but not sure how that can 
happen.

Kelleyaynn








More information about the HPforGrownups archive