The importance of death /Harry and Cedric

[fuzz876i]

No: HPFGUIDX 147273

Lupinlore:
> > Cedric is not suffering at all.
> 
> Alla:
> 
<SNIP>
>  Let's put it this way - because of Peter 
> Cedric lost everything - good and bad things that life may offer, 
> while Harry suffered a lot from Snape, 
> 
> So, while I probably agree with you that Harry's suffering may be 
> greater, Cedric lost so much more than Harry's.
< BIG SNIP> 
 
> Sorry, disagree again - Harry does not forget about Sirius at all 
> and as I wrote in the past me being a Sirius fan and all, I would 
> have been upset if he did. Harry does not go in CAPSLOCK mode in 
his 
> grief, true, but all people grief differently. Harry is a subtle 
> griever, IMO. I loved how JKR handled it, absolutely did.


Fuzz wrote:
With the death of Cedric as well as Sirius Harry
suffers and shows 
classic signs of survivor's guilt. By blaming himself
for both 
deaths Harry is saying that it should have been him
that died both 
times. In Cedric's death Harry thouhgt if he had not
told Cedric to 
take the cup with him then he would still be alive. In
Sirius's 
death Harry had been dueling with Bellatrix and
thought if he had 
finished her off then Sirius would not have died. But
as to who 
suffered more Harry is still suffering and Cedric's
are over.

Fuzz.