The importance of death /Harry and Cedric
susanbones2003
rkdas at charter.net
Tue Jan 31 01:05:00 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 147323
SNIPPED
> Ceridwen:
> And, as someone else pointed out, this was his first remembered
> exposure to a dead body; Cedric was near Harry's age; Harry was
> already emotionally on the edge as Sherry points out; somebody else
> mentions that he also has to bring the body back to the Diggorys
> which will be emotional in itself as he feels their grief; Cedric
> isn't as close as Sirius, so the profanity of sharing the loss will
> not be as great.SNIPPED
> Ceridwen.
>
I have been reading this thread and wanting to add that when you are
young and you experience a death of a classmate or another young
person, sometimes it is more of a shocking realization that YES,
people can die. I know Harry had lost his parents but he couldn't
remember it. Cedric's death was real in the sense that he knew and
liked Ced, but as many have said they weren't close. Still, the shock
of his death hit Harry not perhaps for the sake of Cedric but in the
way that terrible things hit kids. It was more about Harry at that
point. Sirius, sadly enough, was the real deal. The heart-breaking
loss kind of deal. I have just started reading HBP again and I do see
Harry fighting to avoid thinking about Sirius, fighting anyone
mentioning him. Then when Dumbledore talks to him in the Weasley's
shed, it was extremely difficult for Harry. His eyes stung. He
couldn't speak. He didn't want to face the loss of Sirius. So whoever
has said that Sirius was a non-issue needs to read further. Life does
go on and perhaps, mercifully, Harry doesn't dwell on the death
constantly, but its effect is there, and can be felt. Harry said it
best when he said Sirius wouldn't want him to crack up. And he tries
his best not to.
Jen D.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive