Some Questions on Book 6

[Renata Souza]

No: HPFGUIDX 147333


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Ed <ed9743621 at y...> wrote:
>
> Hello There!!
>    
>   I'm actually a new member of this group, and yes, I am a great 
fan of Harry Potter. I have just actually finished Book 6: the Half 
Blood Prince and was quite stunned that Snape murdered Dumbledore. 
>    
>   Can anyone tell me if:
>    
>   1. Dumbledore is really dead or would be returning back in the 
last Book (I hope so)?
>   2. Was the killing of Dumbledore by Snape a deliberate one or is 
just a front to continue his spying duty on Voldemort?
>    
>   Looking forward to hear your views and comments!!
> 
> ed9743621
>

Hi Ed! I'll give my opinion only about #1: I think dumbledore has to 
be really dead, because otherwise, Snape would be, because of the 
unbreakable vow.

Reneta Souza