Evil Hermione

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 154876

"Magpie" <belviso at ...> wrote:

> the analogy being made is intentionally 
> exaggerated. Marietta is a student in a
> school telling the headmistress of a secret group.
> Umbridge=occupier, the DA=French Resistance
> and Hogwarts=France. 

Umbridge had taken away the right of assembly and the right of free
speech, she has demonstrated that she is willing to torture student,
she had already tried to kill one student (Harry) and in a
particularly horrible way too, so exactly what part of this analogy is
exaggerated? 

And I might add that the DA wasn't just a anti Umbridge organization
it was an anti Voldemort organization too, but if Umbridge had her way
they wouldn't even know how to defend themselves from him. Now maybe
Marietta didn't realize the seriousness of the situation but Harry did
and so did Hermione, this is not a game this is life and death. 
Marietta betrayed them and all she got was acne, she deserved a dirt
nap.  

> all this stuff about her being in a secret
> underground organization opposing a tyrant
> is just that: imaginary. And cooler than 
> being a bunch of kids in school disobeying
> the headmistress at school. 

The leader of this silly little kids organization had faced Voldemort
4 times and defeated him 4 times, and that is cool indeed because
nobody else can say that or anything close to it, not even Dumbledore.
Other members of this silly little kids group have also shown their
courage and faced challenges that few member of the Order Of The
Phoenix have. And Marietta betrayed them all. 

Eggplant