Evil Hermione

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 154892

> Magpie:
<SNIP>
  Seeing as nobody dies as a result of this isolated 
> thread in the story, it's a life or death game in a very abstract 
way.
> Harry may have realized the seriousness, but he had nothing to do 
with the 
> hex and didn't demand one.

Alla:
Maybe nobody dies precisely because younger generation did things 
better than the older one, no?

We seem to agree that Umbridge IS capable of murder, one can only 
guess what else besides Cruciatus she could throw at the kids or as 
I said what would have happened if kids were put on the hearing in 
front of Wizengamot.


> Magpie:
> Not really, no, not to me.  Peter was an adult who knowingly 
sentenced his 
> long time best friends to death and did it to save himself.  
Marietta rats 
> people out, but that's about the only parallel I can see. 
<SNIP>

Alla:

I already mentioned that I totally see the parallel, but I want to 
add - Peter was at MOST two or three years older than Marietta IMO, 
so adult/child does not really work for me here.

Alla.