Accidental Harrycrux with a Bloodsucking Snake (long)

laurawkids Lauramahan at voyager.net
Wed Jul 12 15:24:20 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 155263

> Tinktonks
> I'd love to hear your theories on how the UV is either fulfilled or
> not in play yet because I'd truely love to believe Dumbledore is
> still alive and well!!!
> 
>

I'm just thinking that as long as someone **other than Draco** does 
not kill DD, then Snape is still in the *process* of helping Draco 
kill DD.  There was no time frame in the UV, right?  Although Voldy 
might have given Draco a DEADline to do it.  If Voldy said "Aim a 
good hard AK at him" then Snape would be off.  I guess we need to 
know exactly what Voldy told Draco to do, for us to know how the UV 
goes, no?  We need to know the exact mission wording that Snape has 
agreed to do for Draco if he failed.  Maybe Snape does some window 
reflection legilimency (sp?) to Narcissa (maybe consentual) and knows 
he's got an out, even if we don't.

Oh, and Snape's look on the tower has to do with how he knows how 
beat up DD will be, since he would have kept having to doctor DD up 
after their practice sessions in the forest.  Maybe it is the spread 
of the AK off the chest that breaks the bones.  Snape knows he will 
be left untreated this time, and feels all this might actually *kill* 
the old man!  

Redhen, whose ideas I love, mentions that Snape wipes out all spells 
during the dueling club practice.  Possibly he could do the same on 
the tower to release Harry.  DD had enough to worry about.

You see, I have little kids who love Harry, and I need DD to be 
pulling a fake, and Snape, the most intelligent, to survive to see 
the end of Voldy, and turn out to be a jerky, petty, but good man.  
And as a Christian, I even will go so far as to say that not one 
human on earth is so bad that he cannot be redeemed - even 
Voldimort.  Ebenezer Scrooge would be soooo proud of him! (Although, 
a deathbed conversion to goodness would be better than having him 
live and be tempted to get very evil again.)  Just my very odd bunch 
of opinions  : )

Laura















More information about the HPforGrownups archive